Where do you get your ideas?
It’s the famous question every writer hears over and over, even unpublished ones like me. A few days before my first NaNo, I told my mother-in-law that I didn’t have a story yet, but I wasn’t worried, something would come. And it did, the night before, so I wrote out a couple of paragraphs about the plot and the next morning I started writing. Easy as that.
(Of course, it wasn’t that great an idea to start with and got tweaked a lot on the way and is unreadable now, but it was also the first novel I’d ever completed, so the way the idea came about wasn’t really what crippled it. Ideas are easy. Expressing ideas is hard. Maybe that’s why copyright law only applies to expression.)
Whenever I hear someone wish she could come up with ideas that easily, I’d like to offer some advice, but the concept of having no ideas sort of baffles me. Ideas are a result of thinking, and if you’re not thinking? Well, I have bad news: you’re dead. Except vampires think. Sometimes even zombies think. Hmm. Anyway, if you can think, you can create. Simple as that. Of course, the process of developing ideas into stories takes practice, and that’s where most people fall along the wayside. But you can’t really practice without an idea to start with.
Finding story ideas is about being open to possibilities and then being willing to seize the baby idea before the little wriggly thing can escape. So for SWORD AND KNIFE, I started my thinking about the story with one line of dialog:
“Once, by the gods, and I thought you were dead.”
I don’t remember where that line came from, except it was one of things my brain produced when I let it loose to freewrite. But then I took the next step, pushing to see who these people were, what they were talking about, and what was behind their words. I had a strong feeling that it was one man talking to another, and they were talking about a betrayal of trust. The language suggested a medieval fantasy setting. Well then, who are they and what are they doing? What was their relationship that they would still be together after this betrayal? What was the betrayal? And so on. Good writing begins by asking a lot of questions.
The line never made it into the story itself, because it doesn’t fit the character’s voice and there are no gods in their world, among other reasons. But the idea of betrayal became one of the underpinnings of the story. It’s the theme that runs throughout and informs the plots and subplots, as well as the relationships of the main characters with each other and with secondary characters. All from one line and the willingness to ask questions.
So the next time you’re fretting because you have no good ideas, just relax. And then pick something that intrigues you, whether it’s a scrap of dialog, a half-formed character, or a setting. And then push. Ask why? How? Just keep asking questions until the story emerges. Really, that’s all there is to it. Until you sit down to write. Then you have a whole other set of problems. But asking questions will get you started.
So what’s your process? Something similar or totally different? I’d love to hear in the comments.


1Melissa
wrote on 18 February 2010 at 22:38
I loved this post. You are absolutely right about asking questions about your characters and finding out WHO they are. That is so important.
I have actually gotten some short-story ideas from “good” songs. Being a huge music fan,I often melt into what the artist is singing about and it will inspire me.Other times,I have had a random scene pop into my head. Like you, I may never use that particular scene or the singer’s lyrics, but it’s the beginning of something.
Thanks for letting me share.
2C.S. Swarts
wrote on 18 February 2010 at 22:40
Glad you liked the post! Music is a great inspiration for me too, though I have to keep myself from getting too caught up in the song and forgetting what I was writing sometimes. :)
3Beth
wrote on 19 February 2010 at 10:40
I draw my ideas from everywhere. Movies, books, songs, people I know, random things I see when I’m out and about… One story I wrote without knowing anything at the beginning except the names of four of the characters, that was it. And you are so right about ideas being all around. Finding a good idea isn’t the hard part. The hard part is taking that idea to the next level.
4C.S. Swarts
wrote on 19 February 2010 at 15:58
Sometimes I think starting a story with minimal information can lead to the most creative solutions to story problems. Now if only the rest of the writing process came as easily as ideas do!
5Voyagefan
wrote on 20 February 2010 at 12:11
I usually look around me, notice my surroundings, when I’m out in public. I get inspiration from other places, too. Pictures, websites, all sorts of stuff. If I see something interesting, I can probably write about it.
6C.S. Swarts
wrote on 20 February 2010 at 12:38
Something I need to practice more is taking inspiration from pictures, my surroundings, etc., rather than waiting for it to come to me. A few weeks ago I browsed through a folder of pictures I have and came up with several story ideas. Keeps the well from going dry.